Computer System Validation Process and Documentation Requirements

What is a Computer System Validation Process (CSV)?

Computer System Validation or CSV is also called software validation.
CSV is a documented process that tests, validates, and formally documents regulated computer-based systems, ensuring these systems operate reliably and perform their intended functions consistently, accurately, securely, and traceably across various industries.

Computer System Validation Process is a critical process to ensure data integrity, product quality, and compliance with regulations.

Why Do We Need Computer System Validation Process?

Validation is essential in maintaining the quality of your products. To protect your computer systems from damage, shutdowns, distorted research results, product and sample loss, unstable conditions, and any other potential negative outcomes, you must proactively perform the CSV.

Timely and wise treatment of failures in computer systems is essential, as they can cause manufacturing facilities to shut down, lead to financial losses, result in company downsizing, and even jeopardize lives in healthcare systems.

So, Computer System Validation Process is becoming necessary considering following key points-

• Regulatory Compliance: CSV ensures compliance with regulations such as Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP), Good Clinical Practices (GCP), and Good Laboratory Practices (GLP). By validating systems, organisations adhere to industry standards and legal requirements.
• Risk Mitigation: By validating systems, organisations reduce the risk of errors, data loss, and system failures. QA professionals play a vital role in identifying and mitigating risks during the validation process.
• Data Integrity: CSV safeguards data accuracy, completeness, and consistency. In regulated industries, reliable data is essential for decision-making, patient safety, and product quality.
• Patient Safety: In healthcare, validated systems are critical for patient safety.  From electronic health records to medical devices, ensuring system reliability is critical.

How to implement the Computer System Validation (CSV) Process?

You can consider your computer system validation when you start a new product or upgrade an existing product. Here are the key phases that you will encounter in the Computer System Validation process:

• Planning: Establishing a project plan outlining the validation approach, resources, and timelines. Define the scope of validation, identify stakeholders, and create a validation plan. This step lays the groundwork for the entire process.
• Requirements Gathering: Documenting user requirements and translating them into functional specifications and technical specifications.
• Design and Development: Creating detailed design and technical specifications. Develop or configure the system according to the specifications. This step involves coding, configuration, and customization.
• Testing: Executing installation, operational, and performance qualification tests. Conduct various tests to verify the system’s functionality, performance, and security. Types of testing include unit testing, integration testing, and user acceptance testing.
• Documentation: Create comprehensive documentation, including validation protocols, test scripts, and user manuals. Proper documentation is essential for compliance.
• Operation: Once validated, you can put the system into operation. Regular maintenance and periodic reviews are necessary to ensure ongoing compliance. 

Approaches to Computer System Validation(CSV):

As we study, the CSV involves several steps, including planning, specification, programming, testing, documentation, and operation.Perform each step correctly, as each one is important. CSV can be approached in various ways:

• Risk-Based Approach: Prioritize validation efforts based on risk assessment. Identity critical functionalities and focus validation efforts accordingly. This approach includes critical thinking, evaluating hardware, software, personnel, and documentation, and generating data to translate into knowledge about the system.
• Life Cycle Approach: This approach breaks down the process into the life cycle phases of a computer system, which are concept, development, testing, production, maintenance and then validate throughout the system’s life cycle phases. This helps to follow continuous compliance and quality.
• Scripted Testing: This approach can be robust or limited. Robust scripted testing includes evidence of repeatability, traceability to requirements, and auditability. Limited scripted testing is a hybrid approach that scales scripted and unscripted testing according to the risk of the system.
• “V”- Model Approach: Align validation activities with development phases. The ‘V’ model emphasizes traceability between requirements, design and testing.
• Process-Based Approach: Validate based on the system’s purpose and processes it serves. First one need to understand how the system interacts with users, data and other systems.
• GAMP (Good Automated Manufacturing Practice) Categories: Classify systems based on complexity. It provides guidance on validation strategies for different categories of software and hardware.

Documentation Requirements:

Here are the essential documents for CSV during its different phases:

• Validation Planning:
  • Project Plan: Document outlining the approach, resources, timeline, and responsibilities for CSV.
• User Requirements Specification (URS):
  • User Requirements Document: Defines what the user wants a system must do from a user’s perspective. The system owner, end-users, and quality assurance write it early in the validation process, before the system is created. The URS essentially serves as a blueprint for developers, engineers, and other stakeholders involved in the design, development, and validation of the system or product.
• Functional Specification (FS):
  • Functional Requirements: Detailed description of system functions, it is a document that describes how a system or component works and what functions it must perform.Developers use Functional Specifications (FSs) before, during, and after a project to serve as a guideline and reference point while writing code.
• Design Qualification (DQ):
  • It is specifically a detailed description of the system architecture, database schema, hardware components, software modules, interfaces, and any algorithms or logic used in the system.
  • Functional Design Specification (FDS): Detailed description of how the system will meet the URS.
  • Technical Design Specification (TDS): Technical details of hardware, software, and interfaces
• Configuration Specification (CS):
  • Additionally, Specifies hardware, software, and network configurations settings and how these settings address the requirements in the URS.
• Installation Qualifications (IQ):
  • Installation Qualification Protocol: Document verifying that the system is installed correctly.
• Operational Qualification (OQ):
  • Operational Qualification Protocol: Therefore, document verifying that the system functions as intended in its operational environment and fit to be deployed to the consumers.
• Performance Qualification (PQ):
  • Performance Qualification Protocol: Document verifying that the system consistently performs according to predefined specifications under simulated real-world conditions.
• Risk Scenarios:
  • Additionally identification and evaluation of potential risks associated with the system and its use and mitigation strategies.
• Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs):
  • SOP Document, specifically is a set of step-by-step instructions for system use, maintenance, backup, security, and disaster recovery.
• Change Control:
  • Change control refers to the systematic process of managing any modifications or adjustments made to a project, system, product, or service. It ensures that all proposed changes undergo a structured evaluation, approval, implementation, and subsequently its impact and documentation process.
• Training Records:
  • Moreover, documentation of training provided to personnel on system operation and maintenance.
• Audit Trails:
  • In summary, an audit trail is a sequential record of activities that have affected a device, procedure, event, or operation. It can be a set of records, a destination, or a source of records. Audit trails can include date and time stamps, and can capture almost any type of work activity or process, whether it’s automated or manual.
• Periodic Review:
  • Scheduled reviews of the system to ensure continued compliance and performance. Additionally, periodic review ensures that your procedures are aligned with the latest regulations and standards, reducing the risk of noncompliance. Consequently, regular review can help identify areas where your procedures may not be in compliance with the regulations.
• Validation Summary Report (VSR):
  • Validation Summary Report: Consolidates all validation activities performed and results obtained. Ultimately,
    it is a key document that demonstrates that the system meets its intended use and complies with regulations and standards. It also provides evidence of the system’s quality and reliability and any deviations or issues encountered during the validation process
  • It provides a conclusion on whether the system meets predefined acceptance criteria.
• Traceability Matrix (TM):
  • Links validation documentation (URS, FRS, DS, IQ, OQ, PQ) to requirements, test scripts, and results.
  • Also known as Requirements Traceability Matrix (RTM) or Cross Reference Matrix (CRM)

By following these processes and documentation requirements, organizations can ensure that their computer systems are validated to operate effectively, reliably, and in compliance with regulatory requirements.

Conclusion

Computer System Validation (CSV) Process, therefore, is essential for ensuring that computer systems in regulated industries work correctly and meet safety standards. By following a structured validation process, organizations can protect data integrity, improve product quality, and reduce the risk of system failures.

Moreover, with ongoing validation and regular reviews, companies can stay compliant with regulations and adapt to new challenges. Ultimately, investing in a solid Computer System Validation approach not only enhances system reliability but also shows a commitment to quality and safety for users and stakeholders alike.

Click here to read more blogs like this.

1